Yes, 1-star only, beware. Initially we were excited to travel to New York from California for the first time, see Central Park, The Met, Broadway, Statue of Liberty, etc. Most importantly, we wanted a nice, quiet, place to stay that was safe, comfortable, and clean. We were very wrong in choosing here to stay.
The owners abandoned us at the airport when we arrived, not responding to any of our texts or phone calls, forcing us to get a hotel the first night because they fell asleep and hadn't given us the access codes to the apartment. This happened despite the fact we had contacted them three times prior to our arrival: the weekend before, the day before, and the day of--and yet we were still left hanging after flying all the way from California.
The next day when we finally got into the apartment, we were surprised to find it wasn't very clean--there was grime on the countertops, some hair in the shower, the floor was dirty, etc. The mattress was so old it was like sleeping in a hole that really hurt our backs. But, still determined to have a good time, we were respectful of our hosts and remained positive.
Without detailing all of the other negative aspects of our stay, allow me to jump to the end. We left after staying 7 nights. When I asked if the owners would consider giving us a refund from the first night we were told that we had left a day early and therefore violated our contract. This form of response astounded me, as it was entirely false, and particularly because the entire reason for us staying in a hotel the first night was entirely their fault and not ours. I informed the owners that I was shocked at their reply and will, therefore, be giving a very honest review of our stay.
I would discourage anyone from staying here. Perhaps in the past the owners kept a clean and tidy apartment, and were kind and accommodating to their guests. However, this is no longer the case. So I say again: Beware.