When I booked this, I did see the other reviews...so I knew it was possible that there could be a parking problem, that noise *might* be a factor, and everything else that other reviewers said both positively and negatively.
Our stay, like pretty much all vacations, had some great experiences, and some, shall we say, interesting experiences too.
The Good: The house we had (Maplecrest, 1 of 3) was gigantic and spacious. While it had 7 bedrooms, they are very small, but each one has it's own air conditioner, so you can adjust the temperature to whatever you want- a huge plus. There were two bathrooms, very clean and modern.
Also, the rooms were spotless (except for one, see below), and the screened in wrap-around porch was perfect for having breakfast/dinner with great views of the lake.
Other great things included the dock area- one of the best around with kayaks/floats and we were easily able to tie up our pontoon boat we rented for the week. The whole beach-front and swimming area was wide open, and with two other families there, never felt crowded. Indeed, I would say it was *comfortably* crowded because we did talk and interact with them- they were really nice- yet far enough for no masks.
The owner (David- lives on property with his family and children) is a fantastic communicator. While there was a glitch in our reservation (somehow the first night was double-booked), we were getting in late anyway, and we worked it out fairly with him.
Finally, every night we built a campfire... you can either build one outside your cabin or at the fire-rings at the lake. David provides all of the matches, fire-starters, and wood (actually, really, really nice dry wood too!), so that was nice to end each day.
David also checked in multiple times and asked how things were, he really cares about the guests' experiences.
The Bad:
OK, so there was a glitch in the reservation process, but David did work it out. When we arrived, we did find some 'natural' issues in the kitchen, including a dead mouse and non-functional oven (he said he was getting it fixed, we used the provided grill as an oven and it actually worked perfectly). And the rest of the kitchen was very adequately supplied.
Some of the storm doors were really hard to close, but that with the oven should be easily fixed by the time whoever is reading this actually rents the place.
Also, the trash area near the parking lot was over-flowing. That needs to be addressed.
Overall 4.5!