We stayed at the Taylor House in March 2022 and could not have been happier. Our family has been visiting St. John for 20 years and have rented various villas all over the island, and this was by far the nicest house and best location we have stayed in. The house was modern, impeccably clean, and well appointed. We traveled with another family, and there was plenty of space for all seven people in our group, including two adult couples and three teenage children. The house includes two generous master suites (and arguably a third), and spacious rooms for the children. The shared spaces, including the kitchen, living room, dining room, patio and pool were spacious and and suitable for gathering of the entire group, but also provided ample opportunity for members of our party to find private spaces to read a book, take a work call (if you have to), or find a quiet place to enjoy the sights and sounds of St. John.
The house is a short 5-10 minute walk down to Peter Bay beach, which we visited most days. There were never more than 4-5 other people there, and most days we had it to ourselves. If you're looking for even more privacy, just swim or snorkel around the rocks at the far end of the beach to Little Cinnamon Beach, which is a perfect white sand stretch with no rocks and calm water - we didn't see a single other person there the entire week. And the house is a short 5 minute drive to all of the other north shore beaches, and just 10 minutes to either Cruz Bay or Coral Bay.
Communications with the property owner, Robert, and property manager, Marcus, were seamless. Both were extremely responsive to our pre-visit questions and inquiries and committed to making every aspect of our visit outstanding. Marcus went so far as to cook a multi-course dinner featuring local dishes on our last night on the island, which was outstanding! At the recommendation of Robert and Marcus, we also hired Chef Vincent Alterio to cook for us another evening, which we highly recommend. Chef has worked at some of the finest restaurants in the U.S., and the dinner was every bit as worthy as an restaurant dinner we have had anywhere.